• twitter-icon
Unlimited Tax Return Filing


Orissa HC Rules on Validity of Single GST Assessment Order for the Same Financial Year

Orissa HC's Order in The Case of Palem Ashok Reddy vs. The Commissioner

An issue was addressed under the Orissa High Court for the validity of multiple assessment orders for the identical financial period in the case of Palem Ashok Reddy vs. Commissioner, GST & CX Commissionerate, Rourkela.

An ex parte assessment order on July 2, 2024, issued by the Rourkela Commissionerate, demanding service tax of over Rs. 5.76 crore for the financial years 2015-16 and 2016-17 has been contested by the applicant Palem Ashok Reddy.

Read Also: Section 12A Exemption Can’t Be Denied Solely for Delay in Submitting Audit Report

As the Nashik Commissionerate previously passed another assessment order for the same duration on 12th July 2024 after the petitioner participated in the assessment proceedings, the challenge has emerged.

The applicant claimed that the ex parte order from Rourkela was not valid because of non-service of notice, a fact confirmed via the postal department’s consideration showing that the addressee cannot be located.

Read Also: Summary of GST Assessments with Types and Process

Opposite to that, the Nashik order was a consequence of a complete assessment in which the applicant appeared and showed their case. Post analysing the facts and hearing both parties, the HC determined that merely one operative assessment order could statutorily exist for a provided tax period.

The court outlined that an order grounded on the merits of the case, where the taxpayer has the chance to show their claims and proofs, must take precedence over an ex parte order, particularly when the latter was passed without proper notice.

The principles of natural justice support the same ruling, ensuring that the taxpayers have a proper chance to defend themselves in the assessment proceedings. The court ruled that the ex parte order from Rourkela was “wholly without jurisdiction and a nullity” because of the absence of proper notice.

Ex parte assessment order dated July 2, 2024, has therefore been quashed by the Orissa High Court and confirmed that the assessment order on July 12, 2024, passed by the Nashik Commissionerate, which considered the submissions of the applicant, is legally binding and operative.

The same decision specifies that when multiple assessment orders are there for the identical period and subject cases, then the one arrived at via the due process and on merits shall endure.

Case TitlePalem Ashok Reddy vs. The Commissioner
Case No.W.P.(C) No.15481 of 2025
For The Appellant byMr. Bijay Panda
For the Opposite PartiesMr. Sujan Kumar Roy Choudhury
Orissa High CourtRead Order

Disclaimer:- "All the information given is from credible and authentic resources and has been published after moderation. Any change in detail or information other than fact must be considered a human error. The blog we write is to provide updated information. You can raise any query on matters related to blog content. Also, note that we don’t provide any type of consultancy so we are sorry for being unable to reply to consultancy queries. Also, we do mention that our replies are solely on a practical basis and we advise you to cross verify with professional authorities for a fact check."

Published by Arpit Kulshrestha
Arpit Kulshrestha seeks higher interests in financial services, taxation, GST, I-T, etc. Writes articles with depth knowledge and is extensive for the same. The resources provide effective articles for the products of SAG infotech which provides taxation and IT software. Writing from observations and researching makes his articles virtuous. View more posts
SAGINFOTECH PRODUCTS

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Posts

Best Offer in 2025

Powering India's Taxation Experts with Innovation

Upto 20% Off
Tax, ROC/MCA, XBRL, Payroll, Online GST

Limited Offer, Hurry

New Tax Offer 2025

Upto 20% Discount on Tax Software

    Select Product*

    Current GST Due Dates