• twitter-icon
Unlimited Tax Return Filing


Delhi HC: Temporary Suspension of Biz Due to Health Issues Does Not Justify Cancellation of Taxpayer’s GST Registration

Delhi HC's Order In Case of Ram Niwas vs. Commissioner of Central Goods and Services Tax & Anr

Determining that the proper officer has passed the order of cancellation of GST registration of taxpayer with retrospective effect, it was mentioned by the Delhi High Court that these orders do not specify any reason for cancelling the GST registration much less from retrospective effect.

The HC discovered that the mere allegation against the taxpayer was that it was non-existent, which was addressed effectively by the taxpayer in his response asserting that he needed to proceed to Rajasthan because of his father’s poor health.

Read Also: GSTIN Can’t be Cancelled Retrospectively U/S 29 (2) If GST Returns Weren’t Filed

Meanwhile when the visit was scheduled by the department then the taxpayer was travelling to Rajasthan and for the same reason his business place was closed and it was assumed that the taxpayer does exist, the court mentioned.

The HC, temporary suspension of business measures for poor health shall not want cancellation of GST registration for taxpayers.

The Division Bench of Justice Yashwant Varma and Justice Ravinder Dudeja marked that the retrospective GST registration cancellation has a cascading effect inasmuch as the related authorities shall refuse the ITC to other taxpayers who may have obtained supplies via the taxpayer.

Case Facts

An enquiry was performed for the non-genuine assessees as a part of the special drive for the GSTINs verification and the officers of Anti Evasion, CGST visited the taxpayer’s premises. In that visit at the registered address, the taxpayer was discovered not present. Therefore SCN in Form GST REG-17 was furnished which resulted in the retrospective registration cancellation.

Delhi High Court Observations

In terms of Section 29(2) of the CGST Act, the bench noted that the proper officer may cancel the GST registration of the person from such date that comprises any retrospective date as he considers it suitable if the situation designated in the cited section is fulfilled.

The registration cannot be retroactively cancelled and can only be revoked upon the proper officer’s objective satisfaction, the Bench stated.

Although the Show Cause Notice (SCN) mandates that the assessee must appear before the issuing authority, the Bench observed that the notice fails to specify the name of the officer or the location where the assessee was expected to appear.

According to the Bench, the core of the proceedings, specifically the SCN, is problematic since the assessee was denied an adequate chance to present their case before the issuance of the final order.

The Bench noted that the circular/instructions from the Department are mandatory for departmental authorities, asserting that the Department cannot adopt an opposing viewpoint or reject a circular simply because it conflicts with statutory provisions. Consequently, since the assessee’s right to be heard was effectively denied, the order violates the principles of natural justice.

As the order does not mention any investigation taking place, the High Court instructed the Revenue to reinstate the assessee’s GST registration and closed the petition.

Case TitleRam Niwas versus Commissioner of Central Goods and Services Tax & Anr
CitationW.P.(C) 13450/2024
Date23.10.2024
For the Petitioner BySumit K. Batra, Manish Khurana, Priyanka Jindal and Siddhanth Sarwal
For the RespondentAkshay Amritanshu, Samyak Jain, Drishti Saraf and Pragya Upadhyay
Delhi High CourtRead Order

Disclaimer:- "All the information given is from credible and authentic resources and has been published after moderation. Any change in detail or information other than fact must be considered a human error. The blog we write is to provide updated information. You can raise any query on matters related to blog content. Also, note that we don’t provide any type of consultancy so we are sorry for being unable to reply to consultancy queries. Also, we do mention that our replies are solely on a practical basis and we advise you to cross verify with professional authorities for a fact check."

Published by Arpit Kulshrestha
Arpit Kulshrestha seeks higher interests in financial services, taxation, GST, I-T, etc. Writes articles with depth knowledge and is extensive for the same. The resources provide effective articles for the products of SAG infotech which provides taxation and IT software. Writing from observations and researching makes his articles virtuous. View more posts
SAGINFOTECH PRODUCTS

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Us on Google News

Google News

Latest Posts

New Offer for Professionals

Super Tax Offer

Upto 20% Off
Tax, ROC/MCA, XBRL, Payroll, Online GST

Limited Offer, Hurry

Big Offer for Tax Experts

Upto 20% Discount on Tax Software

    Select Product*

    Current GST Due Dates