• twitter-icon
Unlimited Tax Return Filing


Bombay HC: GST ITC Cannot Be Blocked Under Rule 86A If Credit Ledger Has Nil Balance

Bombay HC's Order in The Case of Rawman Metal & Alloys vs. The Deputy Commissioner of State Tax

The Bombay High Court recently determined that under Rule 86A of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Rules, 2017, Input Tax Credit (ITC) cannot be restricted if the taxpayer’s electronic credit ledger shows a nil balance on the date the blocking order is issued.

This ruling emphasises the conditions under which ITC can be accessed, ensuring that taxpayers are treated fairly when their credit ledgers reflect no balance.

A Division Bench of Justice M S Sonak and Justice Advait M Sethna stated that, “Therefore, on a plain reading of the rule, if on the date of issuing the impugned order or on the date of making an order under Rule 86-A blocking the ITC in the Electronic Credit Ledger, no ITC was found to be available there, then, there would be no question of exercising the powers under Rule 86-A or making any order under Rule 86-A to block such non-available ITC in the Electronic Credit Ledger”.

Rawman Metal and Alloys, submit the petition that contests the order on December 9, 2024, issued by the Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, Thane. The order invoked Rule 86-A to block ITC of Rs 12,84,273, even though the applicant’s electronic credit ledger exhibited a nil balance at the time the order was passed.

The applicant’s counsel claimed that Rule 86-A cannot be applicable in the absence of any available ITC, and that such an application was contrary to the plain language of the rule. He laid on rulings from the Gujarat, Delhi, and Telangana High Courts, all of which had ruled that Rule 86-A can merely be invoked if ITC was available at the time of blocking.

The revenue’s pleader in answer said that the rule must be interpreted to permit restricting to the extent of ITC falsely taken, irrespective of whether it has earlier been used. Any other interpretation would essentially make Rule 86-A pointless, as taxpayers could use the credit before authorities acted.

The Court did not consider the State’s interpretation and quashed the impugned order. It said that, “The argument that the Rule would be rendered otiose cannot be accepted because the Rule enables the proper officer to block the ITC as may be available in the Electronic Credit Ledger, upon there being reasons to believe that the same had been fraudulently availed or was ineligible. If the intention of the legislature or the rule makers was to enable the blocking of any future credit that might be available in the Electronic Credit Ledger, then the Rule would have been differently worded to expressly enable or permit such a consequence”.

Read Also: How to Maintain Input Tax Credit Ledger By Gen GST Software

It ruled, “The Rule is accordingly made absolute by quashing and setting aside the impugned order dated 9 December 2024 and directing the restoration of blocked Input Tax Credit equivalent to Rs. 12,84,273.”

The Court said that the restoration must be completed within 15 days of the order being uploaded.

Case TitleRawman Metal & Alloys vs. The Deputy Commissioner of State Tax
Case No.NO. 10928 OF 2025
Petitioner byMr Parmeet Singh, Mr Vinit Dhage
Respondent byMr Amar Mishra
Bombay High CourtRead Order

Disclaimer:- "All the information given is from credible and authentic resources and has been published after moderation. Any change in detail or information other than fact must be considered a human error. The blog we write is to provide updated information. You can raise any query on matters related to blog content. Also, note that we don’t provide any type of consultancy so we are sorry for being unable to reply to consultancy queries. Also, we do mention that our replies are solely on a practical basis and we advise you to cross verify with professional authorities for a fact check."

Published by Arpit Kulshrestha
Arpit Kulshrestha seeks higher interests in financial services, taxation, GST, I-T, etc. Writes articles with depth knowledge and is extensive for the same. The resources provide effective articles for the products of SAG infotech which provides taxation and IT software. Writing from observations and researching makes his articles virtuous. View more posts
SAGINFOTECH PRODUCTS

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Posts

Best Offer in 2025

Powering India's Taxation Experts with Innovation

Upto 20% Off
Tax, ROC/MCA, XBRL, Payroll, Online GST

Limited Offer, Hurry

New Tax Offer 2025

Upto 20% Discount on Tax Software

    Select Product*

    Current GST Due Dates