ITAT Bangalore: Assessee Income 8% of the Gross T.O. if Accounts are No Declared

The Bangalore Bench of the ITAT ruled that “the income of the assessee should be estimated at 8% of the gross turnover if books of accounts are not maintained by the assessee.”

The income of the assessee, Atul Dinesh Seth, was estimated at 10 percent of gross turnover. The assessee contended that the rate imposed is too lofty and it should be reduced to the rate offered by him. The reason being, the percentage of income proposed by him is greater than the trade norms.

On the other contrary, the tax department submitted that the assessee’s argument is without documentary evidence. Consequently, it was submitted that the assessee’s books of accounts are not verifiable so the Assessing Officer’s (AO) estimate of 10% of the total turnover of the assessee is reasonable and rational.

Thereafter, The assessee challenged the estimation of income at the rate of 10% of the total turnover. Finally, The Coram headed by the Vice President, N.V. Vasudevan noted the fact that as the assessee is not maintaining books of accounts, so, the income of the assessee was decided by AO by adopting the method of invoking the provisions of section 44AF of the Act i.e. at the rate of 10% of the total turnover.

The Ruling of the Tribunal

“The assessee has adopted the net profit rate at 4.08% to 7.91% from one year to another. There is high volatility in adopting the rate of profit by the assessee. In our opinion, to meet the ends of justice, it is appropriate to estimate the income of the assessee at 8% of the gross turnover instead of 10% adopted by the AO,” the ITAT ruled.”

Yash Bapna (Ex-employee)

I hold a degree in law, a diploma in mass communication, and a degree in management. Though I am a lawyer by profession, but writing has always been one of the things that I'm passionate about.

Recent Posts

No GST Returns Will Be Accepted If Filed More Than 3 Years Past Their Due Date

An advisory has been released by the Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN) which notifies…

6 hours ago

Delhi HC: Two Judgment Orders Against One SCN Cannot Be Accepted for the Same Period

It was cited by the Delhi HC that the two adjudication orders against one SCN…

8 hours ago

CBDT Allows Electronic Filing of Forms 3CEDA and 3C-O Via Notification No. 5/2024

The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) in an update for the taxpayers via the…

9 hours ago

October 2024 Records the 2nd Highest GST Collection, Driven by Domestic Sales

In October, Gross GST collection surged to 9% to Rs 1.87 lakh crore, the second…

11 hours ago

UP AAR: GST Will Be Levied on the Installation of Electricity Distribution Systems by DISCOMs

Goods and Services Tax (GST) is to get paid on the procurement of materials and…

2 days ago

Bombay HC Quashes Rejection Order for Voluntary GST Cancellation Due to Lack of Stated Reasons

The Bombay High Court carried that as the revocation orders for the registration cancellation on…

3 days ago